An advocate general attached to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has stated that the 1.49 billion euro antitrust fine imposed on Google's advertising arm AdSense was wrongly annulled in 2024. According to the Advocate General's opinion, the General Court made a legal error and the file should be sent back for reconsideration. The opinion is not binding, but it marks a critical waypoint in the EU's ongoing antitrust battle against Big Tech.
What happened?
The EU Commission fined Google 1.49 billion euros in 2019 on the grounds that it had imposed exclusionary terms on rivals in its AdSense for Search contracts. Google appealed, and in 2024 the General Court annulled the fine, marking one of the rare cases the company won against Brussels. Now the CJEU advisor says that annulment was mistaken and recommends the case be reheard. The Court of Justice judges are not formally bound by this opinion, but in practice they tend to follow it in the vast majority of cases.
Why does it matter?
The AdSense fine is one of three major EU antitrust cases brought against Google. The other two — Shopping (2017) and Android (2018) — were largely resolved in the Commission's favor in court; the fines were partially reduced but mostly upheld. The AdSense case was the first instance in this trio where Google secured a full victory at a lower court. The advisor's opinion suggests that even this single win may not hold.
This reflects the EU's institutional persistence. Since 2023, the Commission has also been running a separate investigation seeking to force Google to break up its ad-tech stack (ad exchange and publisher server) over structural conflicts of interest. The revival of the AdSense fine strengthens the legal groundwork behind that larger ad-tech investigation: a court loss doesn't force the Commission to back down — instead, it tries again at a higher court.
Looking at the global picture, the pattern is similar. In the US, Epic Games' lawsuit against Google Play Store resulted in a jury verdict against Google in 2023, and in 2024 Google was ordered to open the Play Store to rival app stores and payment systems. Different jurisdictions, different legal grounds, but the same outcome: regulators and courts are gaining ground against Google's advertising and platform business models one after another.
Who does this affect, and how?
The operational impact may be limited. The exclusivity clauses in AdSense for Search had already been removed following the Commission's initial intervention back in 2016. So no immediate change in practice is expected for competing ad networks or publishers. The real impact is symbolic and strategic.
| Case | Fine (approx.) | Current status |
|---|---|---|
| Google Shopping (2017) | 2.4 billion euros | Largely upheld |
| Android (2018) | 4.3 billion euros | Upheld with reduction |
| AdSense (2019) | 1.49 billion euros | Annulled, now back on the table |
The message for Google is clear: winning at a lower court doesn't mean the case is over. This raises the cost of the company's "appeal, stall, drag out the process" strategy — years of legal expense can ultimately backfire. It also sets a precedent for other Big Tech companies: EU regulators do not treat court losses as final.
What's next?
The CJEU's final ruling typically comes months after the advisor's opinion. If the opinion is upheld, the file will return to the General Court, and the grounds for the fine will be debated again — a process that could take years. Meanwhile, there are ongoing investigations into Google under the Digital Markets Act (DMA) covering issues like self-preferencing in Search and Play Store rules; the outcome of this case could be read as a sign that the Commission will maintain a similarly persistent stance under the DMA as well.
In the short term, this development is immaterial to Google's cash flow — the company's reserves comfortably cover fines that amount to a fraction of its annual advertising revenue. But institutionally, it shows the EU isn't giving up, a reminder to Google's lawyers that a court victory is not a guaranteed ending. Details of the Advocate General's opinion can be found at this link.
Yorumlar (0)
Henüz yorum yok. İlk yorumu sen yaz.
Yorum yapmak için Sinyal'i indir
Yorumlar Sinyal hesabıyla yapılır. Mobil uygulamada giriş yap, yorum bırak.