Nvidia's position in the memory crisis is back on the table. According to a closed-door meeting memo reported by the Wall Street Journal, the company's interim CEO, Colette Kress, acknowledged that the circular financing deals spreading across the AI chip ecosystem carry "major risk." This admission matters because Nvidia is being portrayed simultaneously as a source of demand fueling the memory shortage and as a party financially benefiting from that very shortage.

What happened?

According to the Wall Street Journal, Kress told the meeting that the cross-investment and financing relationships Nvidia has built across its supply chain form a fragile structure. In these kinds of deals, Nvidia provides direct or indirect financing to the companies buying its chips; those buyers then funnel much of that capital back into Nvidia hardware and the memory modules purchased alongside it. Critics argue this cycle inflates real demand, and that part of the spike in memory prices stems from this artificial demand.

Why does it matter?

The circular financing debate isn't unique to Nvidia; tech history has other cases where supplier financing exaggerated demand. In the early 2000s, Cisco and Lucent extending credit to customers so they could buy the companies' own equipment was a key subtext of the dot-com crash. Today's difference lies in scale and the structure of the memory market: HBM (high bandwidth memory) production is concentrated among a handful of players — Samsung, SK Hynix, Micron. While Nvidia's AI chips directly consume this memory, the fact that it also finances its customers so they can buy those chips creates the appearance that both demand and supply are being shaped by the same hand.

The timing of Kress's admission is a critical detail here. Coming from the company's interim CEO following Jensen Huang's departure from the role, this warning can be read not just as a risk assessment but also as a sign of a gap in corporate governance. The fact that such a sensitive issue surfaced in a closed-door meeting during a period without a permanent CEO raises the question internally of whether these deals were born of strategy or necessity.

Who benefits from circular financing deals?

The winner and loser in this structure aren't clear-cut; the picture shifts depending on which party you look at.

PartyShort-term effectRisk
NvidiaChip sales guaranteed, revenue growsA correction will be severe if demand isn't real
Memory manufacturersRising orders, pricing powerCapacity investments become stranded if demand evaporates
Cloud/AI companiesEasier access to hardwareGrowing debt load and dependency
Consumer electronics-Rising costs as memory prices climb

The most fragile link in this table is the consumer side. Smartphone and computer makers are facing price pressure in a memory market competing with enterprise AI demand; that cost eventually bleeds into the prices of finished products.

What's next?

When an admission like this leaks to the public, it opens the door to greater regulatory interest. It wouldn't be surprising if the SEC or competition authorities in the US took a closer look at circular financing deals — particularly in cases where a supplier with significant market power is also the financier of its own buyers. Another indicator worth watching is how Nvidia reports these deals in its upcoming quarterly earnings, and the extent to which memory manufacturers continue their capacity expansion decisions.

Kress's remarks read less like a confession and more like evidence that doubts about this model's sustainability exist even within the company itself. Nvidia being both the party fueling demand and the one profiting from it isn't a scandal in itself — but combined with a persistent leadership vacuum, it leaves a legitimate question mark over just how controlled this structure really is.